• Beating an Efficient Market

    POSTED Aug 21, 2014
    Despite what various racetrack touts and system peddlers say, one of the things that makes consistently beating the races so tough is that, for the most part, pari-mutuel betting markets are efficient. This means that all the relevant and available information affecting the outcome of a horse race is generally known and accounted for. Hence, the final odds are an accurate reflection of a horse’s chances of winning — minus the track take and breakage, of course.

    Sure, there are pockets of inefficiency and irrationalism. Scholars have long documented the existence of a “favorite-longshot bias,” whereby shorter-priced horses are slightly underbet and longer-priced horses slightly overbet. However, such inefficiencies are but ripples on the pari-mutuel ocean.

    Still, the fact that inefficiencies can and do exist provides hope that the races can be beaten — just like grainy, out-of-focus video footage provides hope to some that bigfoot lives among us (often disguised as a broken tree branch).

    In this article, I will attempt to show readers how they can spot and capitalize on inefficient markets — as well as efficient markets — to make more moolah at the racetrack.

    Follow the Money 

    Not to go all “Deep Throat” on everybody, but the simplest way to spot an efficient or inefficient market is to follow the money. Consider the following scenario:

    John Doe is given $2 to bet to win on any horse running at Saratoga on Saturday.

    * How does he choose what race to bet?
    * How does he choose which horse to bet?

    Well, assuming Mr. Doe is logical, one would expect him to play the race and horse that (he believes) give him the best chance of winning. However, even if Doe possessed the superior handicapping acumen of a dart-throwing monkey or one of those omnipotent racetrack touts mentioned earlier, it is clear that any market comprised solely of his wager would have to be inefficient. For, even if we ignored the fact that Doe’s horse would be 1-9, we are stuck with the unfortunate detail that all the other horses in the field — those that didn’t receive any of Doe’s dough — would be lumped together at 99-1.

    Obviously, this is not an accurate assessment of each horse’s chances.

    Thus, even though this was an extreme example, it should be self-evident that less money and fewer wagers equal a less efficient market. Might the opposite also be true? Does more money and more wagers lead to a more efficient market?

    I decided to find out.

    To provide a baseline, I first looked at all sole betting favorites (no favored entries) from a variety of races run across the fruited plain from September to December of 2013:

    Number – 7,996
    Winners – 2,904
    Win Rate – 36.3%
    $2 Net – $1.67
    IV – 2.80
    OBIV – 0.84

    Next, I analyzed favorites in races with the lowest straight (win, place and show) handle on the card (provided the total pool was less than $10,000). As expected, the numbers took a nosedive, giving credence to my hypothesis that less betting/money results in a less efficient market:

    Number – 185
    Winners – 61
    Win Rate – 33.0%
    $2 Net – $1.50
    IV – 2.11
    OBIV – 0.75

    Lastly, I looked at races with the greatest straight handle on the card (provided the total pool exceeded $10,000). Not surprisingly (at least to me), the figures were fantastic:

    Number – 830
    Winners – 320
    Win Rate – 38.6%
    $2 Net – $1.73
    IV – 3.35
    OBIV – 0.89

    In races featuring above-average betting action, favorites won 38.6 percent of the time, lost just 13 cents per dollar wagered (compared to 16 cents for favorites overall) and had an impact value (IV) of 3.35 (versus 2.80 for favorites on the whole).

    The Efficient Data Hypothesis

    Now, I know what some of you are thinking: big deal, Derek, your “fantastic figures” still produced a loss of 13 percent. What good does it do to identify efficient and/or inefficient pari-mutuel markets if one still loses one’s shirt?

    Keep your chin up, Daniel-san. It’s not so much what the stats tell us about these specific instances, it’s what they imply about handicapping in general. Let’s go back to the definition of market efficiency: all the relevant and available information affecting the outcome of a horse race is generally known and accounted for.

    To me, this suggests that “all the relevant and available information affecting the outcome of a horse race” may be overvalued or undervalued in races attracting more or less wagering dollars, respectively. In other words, rather than patterning one’s handicapping around specific race conditions — placing extra value on workouts in two-year-old races, stressing class in turf races, etc. — a player might be better served by using the straight wagering pools to emphasize or de-emphasize traditional factors.

    Take speed figures, for example. Using the database of races above, I compiled the following stats on horses possessing the best last-race Brisnet speed figure over today’s general track surface (AW/dirt or turf):

    Number – 6,353
    Winners – 1,835
    Win Rate – 28.9%
    $2 Net – $1.74

    Nothing to get the pulse racing, right? Well, if you’re standing up, grab a chair (you’ll want to be sitting) and look at what happens when the digits above are parsed based on the size of the win, place and show pools:


    Number – 4,299
    Winners – 1,209
    Win Rate – 28.1%
    $2 Net – $1.70


    Number – 2,054
    Winners – 626
    Win Rate – 30.5%
    $2 Net – $1.83

    In races with less than $25,000 in the win, place and show pools, the horse(s) with the top last-race speed figure produced a loss of just eight cents on the dollar — nearly half the loss produced in races with higher pool totals.

    Get the point? By gauging the relative efficiency of the market one is betting into — be it the first race at Arapahoe Park or the feature race at Del Mar — my research suggests that well-known predictive factors like speed and class can be upgraded or downgraded accordingly.

    And that, my friends, is what good handicapping is all about.


    «Oldest   ‹Older   201 – 218 of 218
    Jane Wilson said...

    Do you find it difficult to manage financial matters? It's not just you. We have a finance case study sample as a way of assisting you in overcoming those difficulties. You will acquire the knowledge and abilities needed to make wise financial decisions thanks to our sample. Why are you holding out? Download our sample case study on finances right away!

    Wintex Fabrics & Fashions said...

    The Readymade Garments Manufacturer's in Bangladesh cater to a wide range of product categories, including knitwear, woven garments, sweaters, and accessories. The manufacturers produce garments for various market segments, ranging from low-cost and mass-market to high-end and luxury brands. The industry is equipped to handle the entire manufacturing process, from sourcing raw materials to designing, cutting, stitching, and finishing garments.

    Wintex Fabrics & Fashions said...

    As an Readymade Garments Manufacturer in Bangladesh, you are a key player in the fashion industry, contributing to the creation and production of stylish and high-quality clothing. Your expertise lies in designing, manufacturing, and distributing a wide range of apparel items that cater to various market segments and consumer preferences.

    Anonymous said...

    Impressive information for the viewer. Our experts are here to provide you with comprehensive assistance and ensure Network Topology Assignment Help that you understand the concepts thoroughly. Get in touch with us today to ace your assignment and boost your grades!

    Palak Mittal said...

    Interesting information for the viewer. Our experts are here to provide you with comprehensive assistance and ensure Network Topology Assignment Help that you understand the concepts thoroughly. Get in touch with us today to ace your assignment and boost your grades!

    fritzbox login said...

    Das WLAN-Netzwerk des reset fritzbox 6490 Routers mit erstaunlichen Netzwerkdiensten. Um dieses System optimal nutzen zu können, müssen Sie es einrichten. Für die Einrichtung der Fritzbox 6490 müssen Sie sich über fritzbox login oder myfritz login an der Benutzeroberfläche anmelden.

    stivejoy said...

    Are you struggling with MATLAB assignments and seeking reliable assistance in Australia? Look no further! Our MATLAB Assignment Help services is your trusted partner in conquering complex MATLAB tasks and achieving academic excellence. We provide you with top-notch solutions that will boost your grades and understanding of this powerful software. Contact us today to get started on your path to academic success!

    Moshiur Rahman said...

    Winstar W37 Price in Bangladesh

    Anonymous said...

    If your SimpliSafe Doorbell Camera Not Working, troubleshoot by checking Wi-Fi connectivity, power source, and firmware updates. Ensure the camera is properly installed and has a clear view. Contact SimpliSafe support for further assistance if the issue persists.

    Techwirex said...

    Good article.

    Any know more about this for check How to Screenshot on Samsung Tablet

    Ariatenly said...

    Fascinating insights into the dynamics of horse race betting markets! Identifying inefficiencies is like discovering hidden treasures. Seeking essay brilliance? Explore descriptive essay help where eloquence meets expertise. Craft compelling narratives effortlessly with the best essay writer service. Your academic journey, like the racetrack, deserves precision and excellence!

    Techwirex said...

    Financial Capital of the World

    simon said...

    "Beating an Efficient Market" delves into the intricacies of financial markets, exploring strategies to outperform an efficient market. The review underscores the article's insightful examination of investment tactics that challenge the efficiency hypothesis. It commends the author's ability to dissect market dynamics and offer practical insights for investors seeking to gain an edge. With a nuanced approach, the article navigates the complexities of efficient markets and provides readers with alternative perspectives on investment strategies. Overall, it stands as a valuable resource for those looking to navigate financial markets with a competitive edge.
    abogados divorcio en virginia

    Mobile App Development Company in Chennai said...

    Thank you very nice sharing.

    danny said...

    The great content on this site good article also thanks for the information real estate contract disputes

    Linda George said...

    Although outperforming an efficient market is a difficult task, investors wishing to obtain an advantage can benefit greatly from the knowledge and tactics provided by this site. Through a thorough examination of market dynamics and the identification of chances for superior performance, readers are provided with the necessary knowledge and resources to effectively navigate the constantly changing financial world. Whether it's finding cheap assets or using sophisticated investing strategies, this site gives readers the tools they need to overcome market efficiency and reach their financial objectives. Bravo to the author for giving investors practical guidance and enabling them to challenge the status quo." "> abogado dui smyth va

    b2b massage near me said...

    great opportunities for people who is looking for luxurious ambiance are waiting in our izspa best in the city 100% satisfy rate since many years.

    Adriel said...

    The viewpoint you present on investment strategies in your blog post "Beating an Efficient Market" is quite persuasive. Readers may easily understand the content because it provides a clear explanation of the idea of an efficient market and the difficulties it poses for investors. To improve the post, though, think about including more detailed case studies or examples of effective market-beating tactics. Providing helpful advice or tools to readers who want to apply these ideas to their own investments could also enhance the content. All things considered, it's a perceptive essay that challenges readers to consider their investing strategy in the context of market efficiency.abogado dui smyth virginia

    «Oldest ‹Older   201 – 218 of 218   Newer› Newest»

    Post a Comment