“We have received a complaint that we are thoroughly
investigating,” noted Lee Park, a spokesman for the New York Gaming Commission,
“and we have sought the assistance of the New York State Police, which has
expertise in video analysis…. I cannot confirm what came with the complaint.
However, I can confirm … that we do have more than one video of the race that’s
being reviewed.”
Of course, there’s little doubt where the complaint came
from. Eric Guillot, trainer of the second-place finisher Moreno, was hardly coy
in his assessment of how Will Take Charge managed to defeat his sophomore star.
“To me, the horse was dead in the water four jumps out
from the wire when he hit him with the machine, he surged,” Guillot told The Daily Racing Form. “Pretty
suspicious why they had a jock change coming off a second place in the Jim
Dandy.”
Guillot was referring to the fact that 21-year-old Luis
Saez replaced Junior Alvarado as the rider of Will Take Charge after the Jim Dandy,
a traditional prep for the Travers, also run at Saratoga.
I know what some of you are thinking: Who cares what
Guillot thinks? The guy is his own reality TV show, one Fruit Loop short of a
box; he makes Amanda Bynes
appear rational.
True, but in this instance, he seems sincere, at least to
me.
“One thing I have with all the [stuff] I talk is
integrity,” Guillot said. “Integrity goes a long way with me. This industry
needs it. This will be a black eye to the industry. But I think if we all clean
up the rats and flush them out, we’ll have no more problems in the future. I
feel sorry for the industry and the gamblers, the people that bet on him at
30-1, for it to come to this.”
In any event, I thought Guillot’s claims were worthy of
my own investigation, so I analyzed
the race replay on TwinSpires.com looking
for clues of a conspiracy.
Sadly, I found more than that — much more. In fact, I don’t
think it’s a stretch to say that what I discovered from the videotape and still
photos that I scrutinized has implications far beyond racing.
I know a picture is worth a thousand words, so I produced
a video detailing my findings (below). After you watch it, I’m confident that
you will be convinced — as I was — that what occurred at Saratoga racecourse on
Aug. 24, 2013, can never be allowed to happen again.
I can only hope that the principals involved will be
dealt with and that this sport — a sport that I dearly love — can move forward
in the aftermath of this insidious event.
Note: The views expressed in this video may or may not be — but definitely aren't — true. Some names have been changed to protect the sane. FREE Weekend Handicapping Reports
Bodemeister is one of the most polarizing favorites of a major stakes race in quite some time.
As the 8-to-5 morning line favorite in the Preakness Stakes, we're not talking about lukewarm or mild favorite either. This is a horse who many expect to win the middle jewel of Thoroughbred racing's Triple Crown, and even has respected national handicappers such as Andy Beyer and Bill Finley--two guys not afraid to go against chalk--firmly in the Derby runner-up's corner.
He has his detractors, of course, but what makes him so polarizing is that many of those who don't like his chances to win (as I don't) also don't necessarily even like him to hit the board. I'm playing the race for Creative Cause, I'll Have Another, or Went the Day Well to win the Preakness. I'll press on that trio in second as well and also include Cozetti, Tiger Walk, and Zetterholm underneath.
Why no Bodemeister for me while others love him even as the favorite? Well, style of handicapping may play a role.
If you're a pace handicapper and a fan of cliches, then Bodemeister hits you right between the eyes. If he's not lone speed in this heat, then he's certain to at least be speed of the speed. He shook off Trinniberg and ran champion Hansen off his feet in the Derby, and no one in this race appears to posses that kind of early foot. If anyone does challenge Bodemeister in the first half-mile he is doing so at his own peril.
But lone speed still has to finish the race. It took a perfect trip for I'll Have Another to catch Bodemeister in the Derby, but the figure handicapper in me says that Bodemeister's effort is neither as impressive as his fast fractions have some believing nor is it an indication of what to expect in the Preakness.
Bodemeister regressed in the Derby. It just wasn't as fast a race as the Arkansas Derby, and while the raw speed was second best, most figure makers didn't rate his Derby performance among the top three.
From a form cycle stand point, the Derby WAS the bounce. Some are asking whether Bodemeister will bounce in the Preakness. Well, he already bounced in the Derby. The real question is if he maintains that form or moves even further backward. If the former then he could win this race about 20%-25% of the time making 4-to-1 fair value, but if it's the latter then he is a longshot to win and even 4-to-1 would be an underlay.
All that is to say that 8-to-5 is too short for me, and I'm leaning in the figure handicapping camp more than the pace one.
But what of class handicapping? Before the figure renaissance one of the most prevalent forms of handicapping was to assess who beat who and by how much. Bodemeister's two wins have come by a combined 18 3/4 lengths, but his last two losses were both second-place efforts to fellow Preakness entrants Creative Cause and I'll Have Another.
I made the mistake of betting Summer Applause in the Oaks only to watch the filly who beat her last time out--Believe You Can--win again, and it's not a mistake I plan to repeat in the Preakness on an 8-to-5 shot.
So you know who I don't like and who I'd like to see win, but let's cut to the chase and see who Toga Tout picks.
Post positions could affect this a little bit, but until the draw tonight, the philosophy behind this line is more important than the odds themselves.
E.g., I expect Bodemeister and I'll Have Another to be co favored. I have them at 5-to-2 on this line. I started off thinking 2-to-1, but that swelled the prices on others.
I started out with Creative Cause and Went the Day Well as co third choices, but bumped up the latter, so Creative Cause is a clear third choice on this line. Daddy Nose Best will take some money, but surely some shine is off following that dull Derby performance at a pretty underlaid price.
Both Tiger Walk and Teeth of the Dog have connections to attract money, especially in the Midlantic region, and the same price as Optimizer makes sense for them. The rest are obvious longshots, and it's just a matter of how long. There's no true bomb in Triple Crown races anymore, so 40-to-1 was my floor for Pretension, though I probably would have made Guyana Star Dweej 50 had he stayed in.
There were no surprises among who the Triple Crown Insider cognoscenti selected in the Preakness Stakes. Joel and I selected Creative Cause, Ray picked I'll Have Another, and Jon tabbed Bodemeister.
That trio will certainly make up three of the top four betting choices in the race with Went the Day Well rounding out the favored quartet, and there's good reason for that.
As Ray (in the video above) and Steve Crist (on his blog) discuss, those who run well in the Derby typically do well in the Preakness. Derby winners are 11 for their past 30 in the Preakness, and while the Preakness win percentage for Derby runner-ups is not nearly as gaudy, the also rans typically run well.
The "new shooter" mantle had a bit of a renaissance in the late 20th and early 21st centuries thanks to wins by Red Bullet, Bernardini, and Rachel Alexandra and "gusty" performances in defeat by Magic Weisner (second to War Emblem in 2002) and Scrappy T (second to Afleet Alex in 2005), but Red Bullet and Rachel Alexandra were both Grade 1 winners going into the Preakness, and Bernardini was coming off a graded stakes win en route to championship honors that year.
There are no such horses with close to those kinds of resumes among the new shooters in this year's Preakness, and I am playing the race for one of Creative Cause, I'll Have Another, or Went the Day Well to win. Bodemeister would obviously be no surprise, but as the favorite against two horses who have already beaten him in a race (Creative Cause & I'll Have Another) I'll try to beat him.
As the race summary from the Brisnet.com Ultimate PPs illustrate, the Derby starters are clearly the class of this bunch. Even the lowly Optimizer has an on-paper edge over the best of the new shooters.
I'll return later this week with a closer look at the field as well as Toga Tout!
As a continued part of the TwinSpires Triple Crown Vidcast Series, Peter Thomas Fornatale reviews the Spiral Stakes from Turfway Park. Race was run on Saturday, March 24th, 2012:
Jon Siegel and Joel Cunningham analyze the weekend's stakes races for another edition of Triple Crown Insider as well as look at the upcoming Louisiana Derby.
MY TAKE: Like Jon and Joel, I didn't feel compelled to put either winner in my top ten list, but I thought both races were honest Grade 3s that I expect will hold their form as the year goes on.
Daddy Nose Best registered a 104 BRIS Speed Rating in winning the Sunland Derby, and part of me wants to say that Julian Leparoux won the Sunland Derby because his patient handling of the stretch runner certainly contributed to his success in this race.
Isn't He Clever ran as good a race in defeat. I don't know where Isn't He Clever fits in terms of the classics, but it wouldn't shock me to see him become a regional derby (e.g. Indiana, Ohio, West Virginia, Oklahoma, etc.) pro a la Prayer For Relief.
I would bet Daddy Nose Best in the upcoming third future pool at 40-to-1
or better. He is one of only six three-year-olds to register a pair of
BRIS Speed Ratings greater than 100. Yeah, he got a perfect trip in the
Sunland Derby, and I hate the cliche that the Derby favors closers
because of Churchill's long stretch or the 1 1/4-mile nature of the
race, but Daddy Nose Best is a consistent sort, who--with six weeks to
the Derby--figures to fire his best shot on May 5. It'd be nice to lock
in a good price on him to win now and then use him mostly as an
underneath play in exotics on Derby day.
As for the Spiral, I was less impressed with its likelihood of becoming a key race among this generation but thought the top four all ran well enough to leave the door open for future highlights with additional development. But again, from a classics standpoint, I don't know that this race fits as a key player. I didn't get the same sense watching Went the Day Well as I did Animal Kingdom (whom I bet in the third future pool last year).
More important than my future bets, though, is that four players are still alive for the $1-million prize in TwinSpires.com Triple Crown SHOWdown by having correctly placed 11 consecutive $20 show wagers on the Triple Crown trail. There are three races this weekend: The U.A.E., Florida, and Louisiana Derbys.
Welcome to the TwinSpires Blog. Our contributors will be continually updating posts to offer commentary, insight, advice and expert opinions on horse racing and wagering. The goal is to help you win more and become a better all around horse player.
TwinSpires' horse racing author, handicapper, and podcast host, Derek Simon of Denver, Colo. offers his insightful, humorous and sometimes controversial take on the horse racing industry. He even publishes the ROI on the picks he gives out.
TwinSpires' harness racing expert, Frank Cotolo follows all of the big North
American circuits throughout the year, providing the best value picks and
latest news from the sulky.
The Director of Marketing for Bloodstock Research Information Services (BRIS) and a lifelong Thoroughbred racing enthusiast and astute handicapper, Ed joined Churchill Downs Inc. following nine years as a writer and editor with Thoroughbred Times.
A writer and editor who has been following horse racing for fifteen years. Peter has written books for the Daily Racing Form Press; Crown; and Simon and Schuster; among other publishers, and regular features in The Horseplayer Magazine.